Home
| 2000 Projects | Nancy
Walters - Project Home
The Worlds of the Renaissance Projects,
2000
Eve's Daughters: the Voices of English Renaissance
Women
A Guide to Women Writers of the English Renaissance
Part Seven: Amelia Lanyer
1. Amelia Lanyer's poetry strikes the reader as skillful and
accomplished. Her works include poems of varying verse forms and
two prefatory pieces and an afterword in prose. She is radical
in both her theology and politics. As a proto-feminist, she argues
for women's religious and social equality. Admired in her own
day, she has piquednew interest as a result of A.L. Rowse's assertion
and documentation that she is the Dark lady of Shakespeare's twenty-six
sonnets addressed to a dark woman ("Shakespeare's Sonnets").
The mysterious, dark-complexioned lady of the sonnets was Amelia
Bassano Lanyer, the daughter of Baptista Bassano, a member of
Queen Elizabeth's recorder consort that included him and four
of His brothers, who were Jewish and had immigrated to England
from Spain. As a young woman, she became the mistress of Henry
Carey, Lord Hunsdon, who was forty-five years her senior. When
she became pregnant, she was married to a Court musician named
Alphonso Lanyer, who reared the child, Henry, as his own. As an
adult, she spent time in several noble households, most notably
that of Bertie, dowager Countess of Kent, and that of Margaret
Russell Clifford, dowager countess of Cumberland, and her daughter,
Anne Clifford. As a result of her time with the Cliffords, she
wrote poetry that established her as a major English female author
(Grendler 3:380). After her husband's death, she supported herself
at least in part by running a school.
2. Student examination of excerpt from "Salve Deus Rex
Judaeorum" ("Eve's Apology of Women") (See document
4)
- Written in 1611, this work retells the biblical story of
the fall from Eve's viewpoint. Lanyer argues that Eve gave Adam
the apple from the Tree of Knowledge because she was good and
acted out of unconscious innocence. Lanyer argues that unlike
the men who betrayed Jesus and caused his crucifixion, Eve was
an innocent. Since women are less to blame than men because Eve
acted out of goodness and men out of evil, women deserve a right
to be equal to men. Lanyer's account of the Passion contrasts
the virtues of women as seen in Pilate's wife, the tearful daughters
of Jerusalem, the Virgin Mary, and even the Countess of Cumberland
with men's wickedness as seen in Caiphas, Pilate and Peter. The
second section is Eve's apology and argument for women's liberty.
- Stanza 1: Pilate's wife begs to be heard. In the biblical
account she wrote a letter.
- Stanza 2: She pleas on Christ's behalf and asks that women
not glory in the faults of men, who were, after all, given dominion
over them. Here Lanyer shows the superior moral quality of women,
who are not only right in judgment but also supercede the men
who were placed above them.
- Stanza 3: Pilot's wife argues that men's indiscretions make
Eve's fault much less. Eve gave only what was good (knowledge)
to Adam, and it was the serpent that betrayed her.
- Stanza 4: Eve was deceived by the serpent; she intended no
harm, but she prefers godlike wisdom to immortal ignorance. Here
Lanyer portrays Eve as vulnerable but pure in her desire for
wisdom.
- Stanza 5: Lanyer plays on the belief that men are morally
stronger than women when she argues that Adam is more to blame
than Eve because he has more strength and therefor should have
refused the apple.
- Stanza 6: Adam knew when he ate the apple that he was relinquishing
immortality.
- Stanza 7: Eve erred for the sake of knowledge, and the Serpent
did not betray Adam as it did her. She did not have the power
to restrain Adam.
- Stanza 8: Eve's only fault is too much love; she wanted to
share her knowledge with Adam. He did not reprove her weakness.
Men boast of knowledge that is actually the result of Eve's eating
of the apple.
- Stanza 9: How can man call Eve evil when she was from Adam's
rib? In weakness she succumbed to the serpent's temptation, but
men betrayed Jesus out of malice.
- Stanza 10: The sin of betraying Jesus is much greater than
Eve's sin.
- Stanza 11: Because of men's greater sin, they should not
pretend to be superior to women. They should also remember that
only through a woman's pain are they born.
- Stanza 12: Displaying wisdom, Pilate's wife call upon him
to refrain from seeking the death of the man who is his savior.
2. Since Lanyer is most likely the woman to whom Shakespeare's
Sonnets 127-153 are addressed, they could be studied in light
of how the subject defies Elizabethan standards of femininity.
Particularly Sonnets 127, 128, 130, and 147 might be rewarding.