Home
| 2000 Projects | Nancy
Walters - Project Home
The Worlds of the Renaissance Projects,
2000
Eve's Daughters: the Voices of English Renaissance
Women
A Guide to Women Writers of the English Renaissance
Part Two: A misogynistic Reading of Chaucer's "The
Wife of Bath's Prologue and Tale"
1. Since the Renaissance inherited the misogynistic views of
the Middle Ages, the anti-feminist allusions in Chaucer's "The
Wife of Bath's Prologue and Tale" prepare students for the
obstacles and the frustrations that Renaissance women had to face.
- In her Prologue, the Wife defends her five marriages by citing
scripture in her defense. By defending herself in this way, she
is emulating generations of men who quoted scripture as the basis
of misogyny. In lines 10-12 she refers to the argument that Jesus
must have disliked marriage because he only went to one. She
refutes this argument by referring to Genesis l:28 to be fruitful
and multiply, to John 4:6 in which Jesus reproves a Samaritan
woman for not being married to her present companion although
she had been married previously, to Matthew 19.5 in which a man
is encouraged to leave his mother and his father and to cling
to his wife, to I Kings ll.3 in which King Solomon had 700 wives
and 300 concubines, and to Lamech, to Matthew 1:9-21 where Jesus
commands a rich man to give all his wealth to the poor in order
to lead a perfect life. The Wife argues that similarly in order
to lead a perfect life one must be virtuous, but then not everyone
wants to be perfect.
- The Wife also argues against the negative portrayal of women
in the Old Testament, particularly of Eve and Delilah. She contends
in lines 699-701 of the Prologue: "By God, if wommen hadden
writen stories/ As clerkes han within hir oratories,/ They wolde
han writen of men more wikkednesse; Than al the mark of Adam
may redresse." In other words, women are evil agents in
the Bible because men were the authors.
- She also inadvertently illustrates the misogynistic stereotype
of the lecherous, loquacious, deceitful, unreasonable woman.
In her Prologue she flaunts her lustfulness: "In wifhood
wol I use myn instrument/ As freely as my Makere hat it sent'
(155-57), "Gat-teeothed was I" (609) "I hadde
the beste quoniam [sex organ] Mighte be," (614), and "Venus
me yaf my lust, my likerousnesse," (617). Complementing
her lechery is her love of ostentatious clothing, pearls and
jewelry, and gadding about, all activities prhibited in Timothy.
Her talkativeness she illustrates not only through the length
of her prologue but also through self-admission: "And of
my tonge a verray jangleresse," (644). She takes pride in
her guile and ability to dupe her husbands: ""For half
so boldely can ther no man/Swere and lie as a woman can"
(233-34) and "For al swich wit is yiven us in oure birthe:/
Deceite, weeping, spinning God hath yive/ To wommen kindely whil
they may live" (406-408). She illustrates female irrationality
when she attempts to reason that men should allow women to have
dominion in marriage since they are more rational and patient.
In line 525 she unconsciously portrays women as irrational when
she states that they want what is denied them: "Forbde us
thing, and that desiren we;"
- In the Tale the Wife makes the overpowering point that everyone
would be happier if women were granted dominion in marriage.
By making this statement, the Wife shocks; she desires not equality,
which would be astounding, but actual superiority over men. However,
she weakens her case for women when the Hag exemplifies the negative
qualities that misogynists equate with females: lechery, deception,
and talkativeness.
2. Even though the Wife herself is not a paragon of female
virtue, she does foreshadow the Renaissance woman's frustration
and attempts to redefine women.