Home
| 2000 Projects | Nancy
Walters - Project Home
The Worlds of the Renaissance Projects,
2000
Eve's Daughters: the Voices of English Renaissance
Women
A Guide to Women Writers of the English Renaissance
Part One: Misogynistic View of Women
1. Etymology of misogyny: Greek "miso" meaning hatred
and "gyno" meaning woman
2. Greek origin of misogynistic view
- Women were viewed as inferior to men in both mind and body.
Greek biology viewed women as innately inferior beings whose
functions were childbearing and housekeeping. Knowledge of embryology
was limited with the result that it was believed that the male
role in reproduction was more active and more important than
the female (source 17, p. ix). In Generation of Animals,
Aristotle stated that " "The creation of a female was
always a mistake, therefore, resulting from an imperfect act
of generation"" (source 17, p. ix). Therefore, females
were considered aberrational males and monsters of nature.
- The concept of female psychology is congruent with the biological.
Because women were Physically inferior, they were also psychologically
weak; that is because they were softer and more docile than men,
they were despondent, querulous, and deceitful. Lacking control
of their passions, women were thought to crave sexual fulfillment.
Female passions were created by the hystera (womb); thus women
were lustful, deceitful, loquacious, irrational, and in extreme
cases hysterical. Due to the absence of rationality and emotional
control, women should be ruled by men in both the household and
the state.
- The negative portrayal of women in Greek literature illustrates
the culture's misogynistic view: Dejanita caused Hercules' suicide
by giving him a poisoned shirt, Clytemnestra slew her husband
Agamemnon, and Livia murdered her husband on behalf of her lover
Sejanus.
- Plato somewhat ameliorated Greek misogyny when in the Republic
he posited that men and women might posses the same virtues.
In the Republic he created an ideal state in which class,
wealth, and gender distinctions are nonexistent. Since there
were no households and ownership of proper, there was no need
to subordinate women. While Plato did entertain the possibility
of female virtue, he limited this view when the recognition of
female equality was precluded by the absence of property and
households; the corollary was that such equality was impossible
in reality.
3. Roman origin of misogynistic view
- The Roman contribution to misogyny is based primarily in
law. Roman statutes stipulated that only property-owning adult
males should administer households and the affairs of state.
Corpus of Civil Law became the basis of the European legal
system. Females were never emancipated, which meant that they
never had the right to legal autonomy or to own land. Women could
not sue for divorce, and male heirs inherited their fathers'
property. Because women were excluded from ownership of property,
they could not participate in civil society. During the late
Republic and Imperial periods the status of women improved slightly
although they were never allowed to participate in public life.
These modifications included the right to inherit and keep property
inherited from their father, the right to bequeath property to
children, and the right to divorce.
4. Christian origin of misogynistic view
- The primary biblical source of misogyny was the Old Testament
account of creation in Genesis in which Eve caused the downfall
of Adam and all of mankind by not only eating the forbidden fruit
herself but also by tempting Adam to do likewise. Other Old Testament
stories such as Samson and Delilah were also cited as evidence
of women's wickedness. The creation story in Genesis also portrayed
women as inferior to men because Eve was created from Adam's
rib.
- The New Testament relegated women to an inferior role. Paul
wrote in I Corinthians 11:3: "the head of a woman is her
husband." I Timothy 2::9-15 cautioned women against wearing
jewels, expensive clothes, or elaborate hairdos but also indicated
that through childbirth women were saved from their sinful ways.
The later Epistles portrayed women as the waker sex and stressed
the subordination of wives to their husbands.
5. Medieval origin of misogynistic view
- In an attempt to exalt chastity, some overly zealous theologians,
most notably, St. Jerome, portrayed women as innately lecherous
and shrewish. Adoration of the Virgin Mary promoted virginity
as the ideal state for women. Virtuous women were good housekeepers,
loyal wives, saints and martyrs. (source 17, page xii)
- The medieval church still subscribed to the misogynistic
biblical portrayal of women.
- Secular treatises reinforced the biblical misogynistic view
of women. Particularly popular were Walter Map's The Letter
of Valerius Concerning Not Marrying and Theophrastus'
Book Concerning Marriage. Witch-hunting manuals also promoted
the negative image of women since the witches, who were primarily
women, possessed the supposed vices of most women but in an exaggerated
degree.
- Males received inheritance, and a husband managed his wife's
dowry.